Urgent rib injuries seen same day · routine appointments within 24–48 hours 020 7459 4367 WhatsApp info@marcoscarci.co.uk
Chest wall hernia · lung herniation · intercostal hernia repair · London

The bulge appears when you cough. It has a name — and it has a repair.

A soft swelling between the ribs that pushes out with coughing, sneezing or straining and settles back at rest is a chest wall hernia — lung or fatty tissue coming through a gap in the muscle between two ribs. It usually follows a violent coughing illness, a chest injury or previous chest surgery. It is rare, which is why nobody you have seen so far has known quite what to do with it. It is also well understood, precisely diagnosable, and surgically repairable.

Page last updated 21 August 2026

Rarebut routine in a dedicated chest wall practice
3classic causes — coughing, trauma, surgery
1operation — defect closed, wall reinforced
20+ yrsconsultant chest wall experience
Rare, not unknown

Everyone you’ve seen finds it fascinating. Nobody has fixed it.

Rare is what every clinician has told you — and it is true. But rare is why you are still walking around with it, and rare is not the same as unrepairable. In a practice built around the chest wall, this is a known condition with a known operation.

Chest wall hernias attract a particular kind of medical attention: the interested frown, the summoned colleague, the “do that cough again”. Being an interesting case is flattering for about a week. After that you just want someone who has seen it before — because you are living with a body that does something bodies aren’t supposed to do, wondering whether it is dangerous, whether it will grow, and whether pushing it back in is bad for it.

The mechanics are simpler than the mystery suggests. The wall of your chest between each pair of ribs is a sheet of muscle. Tear or weaken that sheet — with a violent coughing fit, a fractured rib, or a surgical incision — and the pressure inside the chest will find the gap: every cough pushes a small knuckle of lung or fat through it. That is the bulge. It is diagnosable on dynamic imaging, gradable by what is coming through, and closable with a well-established repair.

“Patients with chest wall hernias arrive half-apologising, as if being rare were their fault. They have usually been examined with great curiosity and treated with none. In a chest wall practice the mystery evaporates: we image the defect, we see exactly what moves through it, and we close it. The bulge that fascinates everyone else is, here, a routine Tuesday.”

Mr Marco Scarci, Consultant Thoracic Surgeon

Decoding what your bulge is doing

The behaviour of the swelling tells most of the story before any scan:

Appears with coughing, sneezing or strainingPressure from inside pushing tissue through a gap — the defining hernia behaviour
Classic sign
Flattens or vanishes at rest or lying downA reducible hernia — the contents slide back when the pressure drops
Reassuring
Soft, squashy, sometimes a faint gurgle or crackleThe feel of lung or fatty tissue moving under the skin
Typical
Began after a coughing illness, injury or chest operationThe three classic origins — nearly every chest wall hernia has one of them in its story
Fits the pattern
Stuck out, hard, tense and very painfulA bulge that will no longer reduce, especially with vomiting or feeling unwell, may be trapped tissue
A&E now
Dynamic ultrasound + CT with a “bear down” manoeuvreWatches the hernia happen, measures the defect, and shows exactly what comes through it
The answer

A hernia that hides in the clinic room is a classic problem — which is why imaging here is dynamic: an ultrasound while you cough, or a CT performed while you bear down (a Valsalva manoeuvre), makes the hernia demonstrate itself on demand. It cannot be shy for the scanner.

Three classic origins

How a chest wall gets a hole in it

Almost every chest wall hernia traces back to one of three stories — and knowing which one is yours shapes the repair.

The coughing fit

Cough-induced hernia

The story: a violent coughing illness — pneumonia, whooping cough, a brutal winter virus — then a tearing pain, and days or weeks later a bulge that appears with every cough.

What happened: coughing generates enormous pressure; a hard enough fit can tear intercostal muscle, and sometimes fracture a rib or rupture the costal margin alongside.

Worth knowing: patients with cough-induced hernias are the most disbelieved of all — “a cough can’t do that”. It can, it did, and the torn margin often needs assessing together with the hernia.

Related: costal margin rupture →
The injury

Post-traumatic hernia

The story: rib fractures from a fall, crush or road accident — and once the bruising settles, a soft swelling at the injury site that moves with breathing and coughing.

What happened: the same force that broke the ribs tore the muscle sheet between them; the fracture healed, the muscle gap did not.

Worth knowing: a post-injury hernia is frequently missed on the initial trauma scans because it develops as the swelling resolves. It can — and often should — be repaired together with any unhealed fracture, in one operation.

Related: rib fractures →
The operation

Post-surgical hernia

The story: previous chest surgery — a thoracotomy, keyhole ports or a chest drain site — and months or years later, a bulge at or near the scar.

What happened: every chest incision passes through the intercostal muscles; occasionally the closure stretches or gives way over time, leaving a defect under the healed skin.

Worth knowing: this is a recognised complication of even well-performed chest surgery — not evidence that your operation was done badly. Many patients feel awkward taking it back to their original surgeon; you are welcome here instead, and the repair is standard work.

And the few without a story

Spontaneous & congenital hernias

A small number of chest wall hernias arrive with no injury, no illness and no operation — a natural point of weakness in the muscle that pressure eventually found. The absence of a cause changes nothing about the assessment or the repair: the defect is imaged, measured and closed in exactly the same way.

Book an assessment
What’s actually coming through

Two kinds of chest wall hernia — and why the difference matters

The imaging answers one crucial question: what is in the bulge? The answer sets the pace of treatment.

Upper & mid chest

Lung herniation

A knuckle of lung pushes between the ribs with each cough or strain — unsettling to feel, but the lung itself is rarely harmed, and trapped lung tissue is uncommon. Small, comfortable lung hernias can reasonably be monitored; repair is offered for pain, growth, or the entirely legitimate wish not to live with a lung that visits the outside.

Pace: planned, unhurried — surveillance or elective repair, decided together with the imaging on screen.

Lower chest & costal margin

Fat & abdominal-content hernias

Through defects in the lower intercostal spaces or at the costal margin, it can be fatty tissue — or occasionally abdominal contents — that comes through. These behave like hernias elsewhere in the abdomen: usually reducible and safe day to day, but with a real, if small, risk of tissue becoming trapped.

Pace: these lean towards earlier planned repair rather than long surveillance — closing the defect removes the trapping risk for good.

Surveillance or repair — never limbo

Treatment options, from watchful waiting to definitive repair

Not every chest wall hernia needs an operation. Every chest wall hernia needs a decision — made with proper imaging, not by default.

Structured surveillance

For small, comfortable lung hernias: a confirmed diagnosis, a measured defect, and a planned interval scan to check for change — with clear instructions on the symptoms that would bring the plan forward. Watching is an active choice with a safety net, not the absence of one.

Small & symptom-free

Planned surgical repair

The definitive treatment: the defect is exposed, the herniated tissue returned, the ribs re-approximated and the gap closed — reinforced with mesh or, where the ribs themselves are unstable, titanium plates. Combined with fracture fixation or costal margin repair when those coexist. Typically one to two nights in hospital.

Symptomatic or enlarging

Expedited repair

For hernias with a trapping risk — abdominal-content hernias at the lower chest, or any hernia that is becoming harder to reduce — the same operation, moved up the queue. And a bulge that is already stuck, hard and severely painful is an emergency for A&E today, not a clinic appointment.

Trapping risk
0chest wall hernias that close on their own

A hole in muscle does not knit shut under pressure

Unlike a fractured rib, a hernia defect has nothing pulling its edges together — and every cough pushes them apart. Established hernias therefore stay the same or slowly enlarge; they do not resolve. That is not a reason for alarm, but it is the reason “wait and see if it goes away” is the one plan that cannot work — the honest choice is between informed surveillance and repair.

Patient outcomes

Three rare hernias — three ordinary, excellent outcomes

★★★★★

“Pneumonia left me with a tearing pain, and a month later a bulge popped out at my lower ribs every time I coughed. My GP had honestly never seen one; A&E photographed it. Mr Scarci knew what it was before I’d finished the sentence — the scan showed the torn muscle and a ruptured costal margin behind it. He repaired both in one operation. No bulge since, and I finally stopped being a curiosity.”

Cough-induced hernia with costal margin rupture, repaired · verified review
★★★★★

“Two years after my lung operation a soft swelling appeared next to the scar. I felt embarrassed taking it back — as if I were complaining about the surgery that saved me. Mr Scarci was completely matter-of-fact: a recognised thing, nobody’s failure, fixable. Mesh repair, two nights in, and my chest wall is flat and solid again. The embarrassment turned out to be the only unnecessary part.”

Post-thoracotomy intercostal hernia, mesh repair · verified review
★★★★★

“Mine turned out to be a small lung hernia after old rib fractures. I expected to be marched to theatre; instead Mr Scarci measured it, explained the trapping risk was very low, and offered surveillance with a scan booked and a clear list of what would change the plan. Two years on it hasn’t moved a millimetre. Being trusted with an honest choice was worth as much as the diagnosis.”

Small lung hernia, structured surveillance · verified review

Read 135+ verified reviews

Mr Marco Scarci, consultant thoracic surgeon
Your surgeon

Mr Marco Scarci

MD(Hons) · FRCS(Eng) · FCCP · FACS · FEBTS · Consultant Thoracic Surgeon, Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust

A chest wall hernia repair sits precisely where a thoracic surgeon lives: opening, reconstructing and closing the intercostal space is the daily fabric of thoracic surgery, and the techniques a hernia repair draws on — rib approximation, mesh reinforcement, plate fixation, costal margin repair — are the same ones Mr Scarci uses across his chest wall practice. Rarity is a problem for generalists; for a surgeon who works on the chest wall every week, a hernia is simply the next case.

Every assessment, every scan review and every repair is performed by Mr Scarci personally, from first consultation to final follow-up.

20+years as a consultant thoracic surgeon
5,000+minimally invasive thoracic procedures
170+peer-reviewed publications
Read the full biography
Book a consultation

Five London clinic locations — dynamic assessment at the first visit

No GP referral required. Bring any previous imaging — and if you have a phone video of the bulge appearing, bring that too: it is genuinely useful evidence, especially for a hernia that turns shy in clinic.

Not in London? Remote video consultations are available to review your history, videos and existing imaging before you travel — particularly worthwhile for a condition this uncommon.

BupaAXA HealthAviva VitalityCignaWPA HealixSelf-pay · 0% financeInjury claims
Common questions

What patients ask before their appointment

Is a chest wall hernia dangerous? Part of my lung comes out when I cough.

Far less than it feels. A lung hernia is deeply unsettling to live with, but the lung tissue itself is rarely harmed by its excursions, trapped lung is uncommon, and small hernias can safely be monitored for years. The genuine caution applies to hernias at the lower chest containing fat or abdominal contents, which carry a real — though small — risk of tissue becoming trapped; those lean towards earlier repair. The warning signs of trapping are the same for all of them: a bulge that becomes stuck out, hard and severely painful, especially with vomiting or feeling unwell, is an A&E-now situation. Short of that, this is a planned-care condition, not an emergency — and the assessment tells you exactly which kind yours is.

Can it heal by itself — or can I just live with it?

It will not heal by itself — that deserves saying plainly. A hernia is a gap in muscle with nothing drawing its edges together and internal pressure pushing through it many times a day, so established defects stay the same or slowly enlarge; they do not close. Living with one, however, can be a perfectly sound choice: a small, comfortable lung hernia with a measured defect and a surveillance scan behind it is a managed condition, and plenty of patients choose exactly that. The distinction this clinic insists on is between an informed decision and drift. “Wait and see if it disappears” is the one plan guaranteed to fail; “watch it properly or repair it” are both plans that work.

What does the repair actually involve, and what is recovery like?

Under general anaesthetic, the defect is exposed through an incision over it, the herniated tissue is returned to the chest, and the gap is closed — the ribs re-approximated with strong sutures and the repair reinforced with surgical mesh where the tissue needs it, or with titanium plates where the ribs themselves are unstable. If a rib fracture or ruptured costal margin coexists, it is fixed in the same operation. Most patients stay one to two nights, walk the same day, and return to desk work within a couple of weeks. The repair is then protected the way any hernia repair is: a graded return to activity over roughly six weeks, with heavy lifting and straining last — and vigorous cough suppression and physiotherapy support from day one, since coughing is the force the repair most needs shielding from early on.

I coughed violently, felt something tear, and now there’s a bulge. What actually happened?

Almost certainly exactly what it felt like: the coughing fit tore the intercostal muscle — and possibly the costal margin or a rib with it — and the bulge is tissue pushing through the tear whenever pressure rises. Two things are worth knowing. First, you are likely to have been met with scepticism, because “a cough did this” sounds implausible to anyone who hasn’t seen it; it is in fact one of the classic mechanisms, and hard coughing genuinely generates enough force to break ribs. Second, cough-induced hernias often come with company — a ruptured costal margin or a cartilage injury underneath — so the assessment here examines the whole lower chest wall, and where repair is needed, everything is fixed in one operation rather than piecemeal.

The bulge is at my old chest surgery scar. Does that mean my operation went wrong?

No. Every chest operation — open or keyhole — has to pass through the intercostal muscles, and in a small proportion of patients the closure stretches or gives way over the months and years afterwards, however well it was performed. It is a recognised complication of chest surgery itself, not a verdict on your surgeon. Many patients quietly avoid mentioning the bulge to their original team out of a strange loyalty, or embarrassment, and simply live with it; neither is necessary. You are welcome to bring it here without any awkwardness: the assessment is the same dynamic imaging as for any chest wall hernia, and the repair — usually with mesh reinforcement, since scarred muscle holds sutures less well — is standard, well-established work.

Is assessment and repair covered by insurance — or by an injury claim?

Yes on both counts. Diagnosis and surgical repair of a chest wall hernia is core insured treatment with all major UK insurers — Bupa, AXA Health, Aviva, Vitality, Cigna, WPA and Healix — with cover verified and pre-authorised before you attend and the insurer billed directly. Hernias caused by an accident belong in your injury claim: a post-traumatic hernia is a significant, objectively demonstrable injury, yet one that is frequently absent from medicolegal reports because it developed after the initial scans were done. Mr Scarci documents the defect with proper dynamic imaging and acts as an expert witness in chest trauma, so the injury is recorded to the standard your claim requires — and treatment can proceed immediately, with costs typically recovered through the claim. Self-pay patients receive a clear fixed quotation with 0% finance available.

Rare is not the same as unrepairable.

One consultation ends the mystery: the defect imaged and measured, the contents identified, and a plan you chose — structured surveillance or definitive repair. Either way, you stop being a curiosity and start being a patient with a diagnosis.